#10 of 48: Reuben at I Love New York Deli

So, I'm embarrassed to admit this, but I Love New York Deli's Reuben was my first. Fortunately, it did not disappoint! Who knew I liked sauerkraut? The first bite was total A+ material, but the sandwich got sloppier with each subsequent bite and became slightly less enchanting. While this particular Reuben could have benefited from a bit more dressing, I suspect that might have added to the general messiness of it. Packed high inside of toasted light rye bread, this Reuben stands over two inches tall and, at $10.95, is a fantastic value. We shared it and left feeling quite full. I'm not convinced I'll be able to make it through another 38 sandwiches before returning here for a repeat tasting. Read what Seattle Magazine had to say about it.